Thursday, March 31, 2016

Chocolate Chip Butterscotch Cake

I so badly wanted to show you how to make this cake on Periscope yesterday, but the app was not cooperating and wouldn't load my video. So frustrating! I'll have to try again on the next Milk Bar cake, but just know that the Milk Bar cakes are much easier to make than they look. Yes, they do require some time, but if you plan ahead, it will feel like a breeze.

Layers of chocolate chip cake, butterscotch filling, chocolate cookie crumbs and butterscotch frosting!

Most of the Milk Bar cakes are made with a cake layer, a filling, cookie crumbs and frosting. Because there are so many parts to each cake, I usually make these cakes over the course of a couple days, ending with the frosting the day I actually assemble the cake. You also need to refrigerate overnight, so add that time to your planning as well. I usually like my cakes room temperature, but these cakes are best served a bit chilled. They cut better when chilled too.

Some of the ingredients, like glucose and citric acid, can be hard to find, so plan ahead and start looking for them before baking day. You can find glucose at Joann's or Michael craft stores, but you might have to go to a specialty baking supply store for citric acid.  The hardest thing to find for this cake is the acetate paper. You won't be able to find it at your local craft store. Instead, you'll have to look at a bakery supply store or order some online (like THESE) and have it shipped to your house so you don't have to hunt it down. 

I've made several Milk Bar cakes in the past, including the Birthday Cake, the Apple Pie, and the Pumpkin Pie. I've also created my own Milk Bar-inspired cakes, like the Banana Cream Cake and Chocolate Nutella. This week, I'm making the Birthday Cake again and my version of the Chocolate Chip cake. For the Chocolate Chip cake, I decided to switch out the passion fruit curd for a butterscotch filling and the coffee frosting for a butterscotch frosting. I did use the Milk Bar chocolate chip cake and chocolate cookie crumb recipes. You can find those both here.

I love this combination and am so happy with how it turned out. I hope you like it too!

Chocolate Chip Butterscotch Cake, inspired by Milk Bar

Yield: one 6-inch cake

For the Chocolate Chip Cake, the Chocolate Cookie Crumbs and assembly instructions, refer to the Milk Bar recipe page, HERE. During assembly, just use the butterscotch filling in place of the passion fruit curd and the butterscotch frosting in place of the coffee frosting.

Butterscotch Filling
1 box (3 oz.) instant butterscotch pudding
1 cup cold milk

Mix until there are no clumps. Chill until set.

Butterscotch Frosting
1/2 cup unsalted butter, room temperature
1 1/2 cups powdered sugar
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
1 tablespoon milk
1/4 teaspoon salt
2 tablespoons dulce de leche (I like the Trader Joes brand)

In a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the butter until creamy, about one minute. Turn the mixer to low and gradually add the powdered sugar and the milk. Beat for a couple minutes, then add the vanilla, salt and dulce de leche until smooth, about 2 minutes.


  1. Hi guys,
    Thank you so much for this wonderful article really!
    If someone want to know more about cake with name I think this is the right place for you!

  2. Delicious cakes and i like the cake which ever you shared, thnx

  3. Beautiful cake!
    Try Sugar Flair concentrated food colour. I find that I get the darker more intense colours better than the other brands, especially with buttercream icing.It is best site for cakes in nagpur.

  4. delicious cake :) the color the texture i love cakes thanks !

  5. Your blog is fantastic specially if you have free taste for every dessert you make.

  6. I hope i can my like that this coming weekend. Thanks!

  7. Do you have recipe and tutorial? i want to make it.

  8. We deliver cakes in Indore Same day, We need 3 hrs to hand Deliver cake & flowers in Indore, Online cake delivery service in Indore by Indore Florist.
    cake delivery in indore

  9. I Impressed your recipe and this was very sweet their after I am looking your blog and i have enjoying this time ya hooooooo.....
    Online cakes in Indore

  10. It really looks delicious!! I will show this to my friends right away!

  11. Milk Bar Cakes seems very delicious, i will make my own later!

  12. Chocolate Chip Butterscotch Cake is my favorite cake! Thank you for sharing this.

  13. Nice Post!!
    Thanks for sharing this wonderful article. If you want to give surprise to your friends or family members then go for online cake delivery in Delhi.

  14. that layer looks so special good post keep posting.....
    Online Flowers Delivery in Indore

  15. I Love Chocolate Chip Butterscotch Cake thanks for sharing recipes of this cake, Its Such a good idea if any one find online Birthday cakes deliver in Dubai please visit Ferns N Petals

  16. Collate chip butter filled biscuits have been delicious for the individuals and humans. Acknowledgement of college papers the eatables has been highlighted for the satisfaction and contentment of the individuals.

  17. Wow very nice post for cakes i am really impressed to this post.

    Online Cake Delivery in Ajmer

  18. Thanks for sharing this recipes of this cake online Cake store in indore will definitely try your delicious recipes .It will help our online cake delivery in indore .

  19. Thanks you for this great post with all of these brilliant ideas.
    birthday cake in dubai

  20. Cakeman is the best Cake provider in koregaon park, Order Cake Online in koregaon park, cake delivery in koregaon park.

  21. Thanks for sharing this perfect article. Minimum time is required, It is too easy!!!!!!!
    I found same awesome cakes on :
    butterscotch-cake Cake
    Awesome Chocolate Cakes
    Online Cake Delivery in Faridabad
    Online Cake Delivery in Dehradun

  22. Interesting post that provides relevant information and it helped me a lot. Please keep posting such relevant information.
    Edible Sheets For Cakes
    Best Edible Printer
    Edible Printer Bundle System